Single-cohort transcriptomic screens and cardiomyocyte-only ageing clocks frequently fail in translational heart failure discovery for four structural reasons: (i) non-myocyte stromal, vascular, and immune compartments drive myocardial fibrosis and capillary rarefaction; (ii) mRNA levels decouple from protein abundance in aged post-mitotic myocardium due to impaired ubiquitin-proteasome and autophagic turnover; (iii) disease-associated gene expression conflates maladaptive drivers with compensatory protective stress responses; and (iv) candidate lists are rarely audited against knockout phenotype directionality, cross-tissue specificity, or human genetic colocalisation. Here we report an unblinded multi-dataset discovery and independent causal audit pipeline executed across 12 public datasets (11 human, 1 mouse): 6 human single-cell/single-nucleus RNA-seq atlases (Reichart 2022, PERIHEART 2026, CAREBANK 2025, Kanemaru 2023, Koenig 2022, and Litviňuková 2020), 3 bulk RNA-seq cohorts (MAGNet 166 DCM explants and 166 non-failing donor LV, GTEx v8/v10 LV n = 431, and GTEx AA n = 429), 3 mass-spectrometry cardiac proteomes (Malecki 2025 human LV: 12 donors aged 14–25 vs 13 aged 51–65, 25 hearts, 3,431 proteins tested; GTEx human heart TMT proteomics: 7 LV + 11 AA donors; and Takasugi 2024 mouse heart proteomics, 30 vs 6 months), and Open Targets v4 human genetics. Without any manual gene steering, unblinded decomposition of dilated cardiomyopathy (DCM) recovered positive control ATP2A2 (SERCA2a) blind at rank 76 of 5,677 genes (3rd of the 11 genes left after all filters; ZDCM = −7.994, Malecki human LV protein log2FC = −0.479, p = 0.00039, q = 0.066), alongside candidate TMEM65 (rank 74 of 5,677; ZDCM = −8.008; Malecki protein p = 0.86, no change; mouse heart protein −0.42, q = 0.00014; published cardiac knockdown in mice causes dilated cardiomyopathy; Teng et al., Nat Commun 2022). Systematic auditing eliminated three compensatory stress brakes (ARHGAP1, NOL3, CIRBP), removed systemic non-cardiac ageing markers (ZMAT3 elevated in 9/10 non-cardiac tissues; LTBP2 in 6/10), removed COL18A1 and CBR4, and removed ZSWIM8 (not measurable in human heart proteomes; knockout mice have heart defects). Three computational candidates remain: SYPL2 (lower in DCM cardiomyocytes, Reichart q = 2.0×10−5, MAGNet q = 0.19, protein measurable in only 4 of 25 hearts; note its H4 = 0.973 is a liver eQTL at a 44-gene locus, not heart evidence), PPP1R12C (Malecki human LV protein +0.534, p = 1.1×10−4, q = 0.037 in main test, q = 0.12 in two alternative tests; MAGNet DCM q = 2.4×10−5; Reichart q = 0.13; first intron holds the AAVS1 locus; Bhagwan et al., F1000Research 2020), and TMEM65. None of the four targets changes with age in GTEx left ventricle (n = 431). All candidates are at computational identification; none has been tested in the lab.
Advanced heart failure is characterized by progressive contractile failure, sarcoplasmic reticulum (SR) Ca2+ cycling collapse, mitochondrial bioenergetic exhaustion, microvascular rarefaction, and interstitial extracellular matrix (ECM) stiffening (1, 2). Historically, restoring SR Ca2+-ATPase (SERCA2a / ATP2A2) activity or relieving its inhibition by phospholamban (PLN) via protein phosphatase 1 (PP1) regulation (e.g., Inhibitor-1 / PPP1R1A) has provided a foundational biological paradigm for myocardial functional rescue (3). However, translating transcriptomic signatures from human myocardium into actionable therapeutic targets faces two systematic failure modes:
Furthermore, in our internal audit of single-cohort transcriptomic aging clocks on the 54-donor PERIHEART right-atrial cohort (392,819 nuclei), leave-one-donor-out Ridge regression achieved MAE 6.97 yr, r = 0.4606 (recorded in the model file; could not be re-derived from raw data). Similarly, a multi-tissue audit demonstrated that generic senescence markers (PTCHD4, EDA2R, LINC02388) track age systemically across non-cardiac tissues rather than specifically in myocardium. We therefore replaced single-clock scoring with a 4-angle multi-cohort discovery and 4-gate causal audit architecture.
Every number traces to a named public dataset and an analysis script. The full audit trail is available to partners on request.
We computed donor-level pseudobulk OLS age slopes adjusted for donor sex across four non-myocyte lineages — Cardiac Fibroblast, Endothelial, Macrophage/Myeloid, and Pericyte/SMC — across 3 single-cell cohorts (PERIHEART and CAREBANK, both right atrium, and Kanemaru 2023). Cohort-specific statistics were combined via inverse-variance fixed-effects meta-analysis:
To eliminate ambient cardiomyocyte RNA contamination (e.g., TTN, RYR2, MYH6 soup), every candidate had to pass the Intrinsic Cell-Type Expression Gate inside raw .h5ad count matrices: detection in ≥10% of cells in the target lineage and mean expression ≥0.5× its mean expression in ventricular cardiomyocytes.
We intersected Malecki et al. 2025 (PRIDE PXD050610; 25 human left-ventricle hearts: 12 donors aged 14–25 vs 13 aged 51–65, 3,431 proteins tested), GTEx human heart tandem-mass-tag (TMT) proteomics (7 left-ventricle + 11 atrial-appendage donors), and Takasugi et al. 2024 mouse heart aging proteomics (30 vs 6 months) against our multi-cohort human RNA age meta-analysis to identify two distinct classes:
Across 5,677 genes evaluated in both Reichart 2022 single-nucleus LV (CELLxGENE f7995301: 52 DCM vs. 18 healthy donors) and MAGNet bulk LV (166 DCM explants and 166 non-failing donor LV), 451 genes achieved Benjamini–Hochberg FDR q < 0.05 in both cohorts with concordant disease direction. Cross-tabulating against our chronological ageing analysis and Malecki 2025 human LV proteomics isolated candidate targets and benchmark controls.
Using live queries to the Open Targets Platform v4 GraphQL API plus local GWAS colocalisation tables, we required human genetic association or fine-mapped colocalisation posterior probability H4 ≥ 0.80 for cardiovascular traits, replicated DCM dysregulation, and confirmed small-molecule or antibody tractability.
| Gene | Discovery Angle & Lineage | Multi-Cohort Human Effect Size | Human LV Proteome (Malecki, 25 hearts) | GenAge / CellAge | Literature / Alias Context | Genetics & Knockout Causal Audit Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| SYPL2 (MG29 · Candidate) |
Angle 3 · Cardiomyocyte | Reichart SC CM q = 2.0×10−5 MAGNet DCM q = 0.19 |
Measurable in only 4/25 hearts (GTEx LV p = 0.25, n = 7) |
0 / 0 / 0 | Literature under MG29 (1999) | CANDIDATE (RESTORE): Lower in DCM cardiomyocytes. Note: H4 = 0.973 is a liver eQTL at a locus shared with 44 genes, not heart evidence. Striated muscle dyad tether (Nishi et al. 1999). No change with age in GTEx LV (n = 431). Computational identification only. |
| PPP1R12C (MBS85 · Candidate) |
Angle 1+2 · Mural (1.73×) & CM | MAGNet DCM q = 2.4×10−5 Reichart DCM q = 0.13 |
log2FC = +0.534 (p = 1.1×10−4, q = 0.037 main test) |
0 / 0 / 0 | AAVS1 locus in Intron 1 (Bhagwan et al. 2020) |
CANDIDATE (INHIBIT): Malecki human LV protein q = 0.037 in main test (q = 0.12 in two alternative tests). Scaffolds PP1 holoenzyme. Contains AAVS1 safe-harbour locus in intron 1 (Bhagwan et al., F1000Research 2020); requires unedited iPSC lines. Computational identification only. |
| TMEM65 (Candidate, Rank 74) |
Angle 2 · Cardiomyocyte | Rank 74 of 5,677 genes ZDCM = −8.008 |
Mouse Prot −0.42 (q = 0.00014) Human Prot p = 0.86 (no change) |
0 / 0 / 0 | 11 / 4 | CANDIDATE (RESTORE): Inner mitochondrial membrane / intercalated disc protein. Cardiac knockdown in mice causes dilated cardiomyopathy (Teng et al., Nat Commun 2022). No change with age in GTEx LV (n = 431). Computational identification only. |
| ATP2A2 (SERCA2a Benchmark) |
Positive Control | Rank 76 of 5,677 genes (3rd of 11) ZDCM = −7.994 |
log2FC = −0.479 (p = 0.00039, q = 0.066) |
0 / 0 / 0 | 91 / 18 | POSITIVE CONTROL BENCHMARK (RESTORE): Completely unsteered blind recovery (zero script hardcoding). Sarcoplasmic reticulum Ca2+-ATPase; CUPID gene therapy benchmark. No change with age in GTEx LV (n = 431). |
| ZSWIM8 (Removed) |
Removed from Portfolio | ZRNA = +0.58 (flat) Not measurable in human LV MS |
Not measurable (quantified in only 7/25 hearts) |
0 / 0 / 0 | 0 / 2 | REMOVED (NOT MEASURABLE / KO LETHAL): Not measurable in either human heart proteome (Malecki or GTEx LV). Zswim8 knockout mice have severe heart defects and die as newborns. Recommendation to inhibit withdrawn. |
| COL18A1 (Endostatin · Removed) |
Removed from Portfolio | GTEx LV age: p = 0.991 (slope = −0.000034) |
log2FC = +0.559 (p = 0.048) GTEx LV p = 0.027 (qBH = 1.0) |
0 / 0 / 0 | 16 / 12 | REMOVED (NO LV AGEING): Removed from portfolio: does not change with age in GTEx left ventricle (p = 0.991, n = 431). |
| ZMAT3 (WIG-1) |
Angle 1 · Fibroblast (0.867×) | FB SC Age Z = +4.808 (q = 0.0056) Bulk Age Meta-Z = +7.94 (inflated) |
Not detected in human LV hearts (0/25) | 0 / 0 / 0 | 2 / 1 | DEMOTED (UNIVERSAL SYSTEMIC AGEING): Pre-registered SAP v3 GTEx 11-tissue model demonstrates elevated expression in 9 of 10 non-cardiac tissues (ratio 0.41×). Universal p53 ageing marker, not a cardiac-specific target. |
| LTBP2 | Angle 1 · Fibroblast (3.1×) | FB SC Age Z = +2.762 Bulk Age Meta-Z = +6.89 (inflated) |
log2FC = +0.585 (p = 0.418, not significant) |
0 / 0 / 0 | 47 / 11 | DEMOTED (UNIVERSAL SYSTEMIC FIBROSIS): Pre-registered SAP v3 model demonstrates elevated expression in 6 of 10 non-cardiac tissues. General fibrotic marker rather than heart-specific driver. |
| CBR4 | Angle 2 · Cardiomyocyte (1.5×) | ZDCM = −7.230 Bulk Age p = 0.127 (null) |
log2FC = +0.269 (p = 0.0497 — sign flip) |
0 / 0 / 0 | 1 / 0 | DEMOTED (DISCORDANT PROTEIN DIRECTION): Human LV protein increases (+0.269), directly contradicting the "decreases with age → restore" hypothesis. Bulk cardiac ageing is null (p = 0.127). |
| LGR4 | Angle 3 · Genetics-First (H4 = 0.910) | ZDCM = −7.568 FB SC Age Z = +2.04 |
Low-abundance GPCR | 0 / 0 / 0 | 17 / 7 | HOLD (LINEAGE PLEIOTROPY CONFLICT): Cardiomyocyte vs. macrophage knockout models show opposing post-MI remodeling phenotypes; held pending lineage-restricted assays. |
| ARHGAP1 · NOL3 · CIRBP | Controls & Filters | Elevated in Ageing & Stress | Elevated in Proteomics | ARHGAP1: Yes (#249/#13) | Multiple | REJECTED (COMPENSATORY STRESS BRAKES): Loss-of-function phenotypes in mouse models cause premature ageing (Arhgap1), accelerated dilated LV failure (Nol3), or ferroptotic injury (Cirbp). |
To ensure that no candidate represents a known aging database entry or a compensatory stress brake, our audit enforced four sequential gates. Every number traces to a named public dataset and an analysis script. The full audit trail is available to partners on request:
mousePhenotypes (Mammalian Phenotype ontology MP:0005385 cardiovascular system) and published mouse knockout studies to verify whether loss-of-function mimics or rescues pathology.Our unblinded genome-wide findings converge directly onto four mechanistic pillars of clinical heart failure gene and RNA therapy: